Best AI Receptionist vs Ruby: The Complete 2025 Comparison

Ruby Receptionists built its reputation on premium live answering. US-based receptionists, professional service, trusted by thousands of businesses. The brand promises quality, and for years, it delivered.

Then you get the bill.

$319/month sounds reasonable - until overages push it to $700. Then $900. Then that unexpectedly busy month hits $1,200. In 2021, Ruby faced a $12 million class action settlement over billing practices. The complaints haven't stopped.

This guide compares Ruby honestly against AI receptionist alternatives. We'll show what Ruby does well, where it fails, and help you decide whether premium pricing delivers premium value - or whether flat-rate AI makes more sense for your business.

Ruby Receptionists: What You Need to Know

Ruby launched in 2003 as a virtual receptionist service for small businesses and professionals. The concept was simple: instead of hiring an in-house receptionist, businesses could route calls to Ruby's team of live, US-based professionals.

For years, the model worked. Law firms, healthcare practices, and professional services loved having real humans answer calls without the overhead of full-time staff. Ruby grew to serve thousands of businesses nationwide.

In 2019, private equity acquired Ruby. That's when many customers noticed changes - not always for the better.

Today, Ruby positions itself as a premium service. They integrate with tools like Clio, Rocket Matter, Calendly, and Salesforce. They offer mobile apps for real-time call management. They provide bilingual support during limited hours (weekdays 6am-5pm Pacific).

The service quality remains generally good. The problem is how you pay for it.

The Pricing Problem: Ruby's Per-Minute Trap

How Ruby's Pricing Actually Works

Ruby's published pricing looks straightforward:

What they don't emphasize: those minutes disappear fast.

The Per-Minute Trap

Here's what most small businesses discover too late:

The 30-second minimum. Every call is billed at least 30 seconds. Someone calls, realizes wrong number, hangs up after 5 seconds? That's 30 seconds. Robocall about car warranties? 30 seconds. Spam? 30 seconds. You're paying for calls that provide zero value.

Average calls run 2-4 minutes. A customer calling to schedule an appointment takes 3 minutes minimum. Someone with questions about your services? Easily 5-7 minutes. That "100 minutes" isn't 100 calls - it's 25-50 calls if you're lucky.

No overage alerts. Several Ruby customers report bills jumping from $660 to over $5,100 without warning. There's no text when you hit 80%. No email at 90%. Just a surprise bill at month end.

What "100 Minutes" Really Gets You

Let's do the math for a typical contractor:

• Average of 60 calls per month
• Average call length: 3.5 minutes
• Total minutes needed: 210

With Ruby's 100-minute plan ($319/month):

• 100 minutes included
• 110 minutes overage at $3.19 = $350.90
• Monthly total: $669.90
• Annual cost: $8,039

That's over eight thousand dollars annually - for phone answering.

When Bills Explode

Ruby customers across review sites share similar stories:

"Complete bait and switch program. Bill went from reasonable to insane."

"67 duplicate calls for which we were billed despite providing documentation."

"Bills unexpectedly skyrocketed from $660 to $5,100 with no notice. No one explained why."

These aren't isolated complaints. They're a pattern.

Alt text: Table showing Ruby's $319-859 monthly base costs plus $3.19 per-minute overage rates

What Ruby Does Well: An Honest Assessment

Despite the billing issues, Ruby isn't a bad service. They're a good service with a problematic pricing model. Here's where they genuinely excel:

Live Human Connection

When someone calls a Ruby customer, a real person answers. Not an IVR menu. Not a robot. A trained human who can read emotional cues, build rapport, and adapt to unexpected situations.

For businesses where caller trust matters - personal injury attorneys, grief counselors, high-end consultants - that human touch has real value.

Professional Training Standards

Ruby receptionists receive training on phone etiquette, script adherence, and customer service basics. They learn to represent your business professionally. Most calls sound seamless - callers often don't realize they're talking to an outside service.

Industry-Specific Experience

Ruby serves thousands of law firms. They understand legal intake. They know healthcare compliance. They've handled calls for professional services for two decades. That experience translates to fewer mistakes on specialized calls.

Bilingual Support

Ruby offers Spanish-language receptionists - though only during limited hours (weekdays 6am-5pm Pacific). For businesses serving Spanish-speaking customers, this adds real value during business hours.

HIPAA Compliance

Healthcare practices need HIPAA-compliant answering. Ruby offers secure handling for patient information. This matters for medical offices, therapy practices, and healthcare-adjacent businesses.

If your business requires extended human conversation on most calls, Ruby's strengths are genuine. The question is whether those strengths justify the cost.

Ruby's Documented Issues: Beyond Opinion

This isn't about trashing a competitor. It's about documented problems you should know before signing up.

The $12 Million Class Action

In 2021, Ruby was ordered to pay $12 million in damages following a class action lawsuit. The suit alleged deceptive billing practices - specifically that customers were charged for calls and minutes in ways that weren't clearly disclosed.

This wasn't a frivolous lawsuit. It was a certified class action that resulted in substantial damages. The billing model that caused those problems remains largely unchanged.

Billing Complaints Continue

Post-lawsuit, customer complaints persist across review platforms:

On ConsumerAffairs: "They told me I'd receive alerts when approaching my minute limit. There was no alert. My bill went from $660 to $5,100 with no explanation."

On Capterra: "30 seconds of receptionist minutes charged for hangups. We're paying for spam calls."

On G2: "Complete bait and switch. The pricing they quote isn't what you pay."

The pattern: customers sign up expecting predictable costs, then discover per-minute billing plus no overage warnings equals surprise bills.

Post-Acquisition Quality Concerns

Since the 2019 acquisition, long-time customers report changes:

"Since the company changed ownership, it has gone downhill. Customer complaints through the roof and none being addressed."

"Receptionists unprofessional, sounded bored, and do not follow directions on how to handle calls."

"Clients often heard dogs barking in the background."

Not every customer has these experiences. But enough do that it's worth noting.

Customer Support Failures

Getting help when something goes wrong is reportedly difficult:

"No support line to call - just a receptionist who takes a message and passes it to a 'Happiness Team' who never calls back."

"Contacted them with an issue, they sometimes call back 3 days later."

For a service you're paying $500-1,000+/month for, that's not acceptable.

AI Receptionist Alternative: The Flat-Rate Solution

The alternative to Ruby's per-minute model is AI receptionist services that charge flat monthly rates regardless of call volume.

How AI Receptionists Work

AI receptionists use natural language processing to understand and respond to callers. When someone calls your business, AI answers using your custom greeting, handles common questions from your knowledge base, books appointments on your calendar, takes detailed messages, and routes emergencies to you immediately.

Modern AI sounds conversational, not robotic. Many callers don't realize they're talking to AI for routine interactions.

The Flat-Rate Advantage

NextPhone charges $199/month with unlimited calls. That's:

• No per-minute billing
• No overage charges
• No surprise bills
• Same price whether you get 50 calls or 500

Annual cost: $2,388 - compared to $8,000+ for Ruby at similar call volumes.

What AI Does Better

Beyond pricing, AI offers genuine advantages:

True 24/7/365 availability. AI answers at 2 AM on Christmas. Ruby's human team doesn't. For businesses with after-hours emergencies, this matters.

Instant answers. AI responds in 6-8 seconds. No queue, no hold music, no "please wait while I transfer you." Industry research shows 15.9% of calls contain urgency language. Instant response captures those customers before they call competitors.

Perfect message capture. AI transcribes verbatim. Customer says "My name is Michael Thompson, T-H-O-M-P-S-O-N, call me at 555-234-8876 anytime except Thursday mornings." You get exactly that. Human receptionists sometimes get names wrong, mishear numbers, or forget details.

Spam filtering. Research shows 7% of business calls are spam and robocalls. AI identifies and blocks these automatically. You don't see them, and you definitely don't pay for them (unlike Ruby's 30-second minimum billing).

Unlimited scalability. Busy season doubles your call volume? Same $199/month. With Ruby, your bill doubles too.

Alt text: AI receptionist advantages including 24/7 coverage, flat pricing, instant answers, and spam blocking

Feature-by-Feature Comparison

Here's how Ruby and AI receptionist compare across key factors:

The key tradeoff: Ruby offers human empathy and complex conversation handling. AI offers predictable pricing, instant answers, and 24/7 coverage. Neither is universally "better" - best choice depends on your call patterns.

Alt text: Feature comparison showing Ruby vs AI receptionist across 12 key factors

Cost Comparison: Real Numbers at Different Volumes

Let's get specific about what you'd actually pay.

Low Volume: 50 Calls/Month

Average 3 minutes per call = 150 minutes needed

Ruby (100-minute plan):

• Base: $319
• Overage (50 min x $3.19): $159.50
• Monthly: $478.50 |
• Annual: $5,742**

AI Receptionist:

• Monthly: $199 |
• Annual: $2,388**

Annual Savings: $3,354

Medium Volume: 100 Calls/Month

Average 3 minutes per call = 300 minutes needed

Ruby (200-minute plan):

• Base: $599
• Overage (100 min x $3.19): $319
• Monthly: $918 |
• Annual: $11,016**

AI Receptionist:

• Monthly: $199 |
• Annual: $2,388**

Annual Savings: $8,628

High Volume: 200 Calls/Month

Average 3 minutes per call = 600 minutes needed

Ruby (500-minute plan):

• Base: $859
• Overage (100 min x $3.19): $319
• Monthly: $1,178 |
• Annual: $14,136**

AI Receptionist:

• Monthly: $199 |
• Annual: $2,388**

Annual Savings: $11,748

The Hidden Costs

Ruby's hidden costs:

• 30 seconds billed for every hangup, spam call, wrong number
• No overage alerts = surprise bills
• Time spent disputing billing issues
• Staff time managing unpredictable budget line

AI's hidden costs:

• Your time setting up (1-2 hours initially)
• Occasional transcript review
• Updating knowledge base as your business changes

The math heavily favors AI for any business watching costs.

Alt text: Chart comparing Ruby vs AI receptionist annual costs at 50, 100, and 200 calls per month

When Ruby Is Still Worth It

Being fair: Ruby can make sense for certain businesses. Here's when the premium pricing might justify itself.

Every Call Needs Extended Conversation

If your average call is 10+ minutes of back-and-forth consultation, the human element matters. Think: complex legal intake, detailed project scoping, sensitive personal matters. AI handles these adequately but not expertly.

Human Empathy Is Business-Critical

Grief counselors. Personal injury attorneys handling traumatic cases. Mental health practices. When emotional intelligence is core to your service, human receptionists provide genuine value AI can't replicate.

Budget Allows $500-1,000+/Month

If answering costs of $6,000-12,000/year fit comfortably in your budget and the human touch adds demonstrable value, Ruby's pricing becomes less problematic. Not every business needs to optimize this line item.

Very Low Call Volume

If you get under 30 calls monthly and most are complex conversations, Ruby's 100-minute plan might actually fit. At 20 calls averaging 4 minutes, you'd stay within 80 minutes and pay the base $319 - still expensive, but not outrageous.

Specific Regulatory Requirements

Some industries have regulations requiring human interaction for certain calls. If that's your situation, Ruby (or similar live answering services) may be necessary regardless of cost.

When AI Receptionist Wins

For the majority of small businesses, AI receptionist is the clear winner. Here's why.

Most Calls Are Routine

Industry research shows the breakdown of typical small business calls:

• 31.1% general service requests
• 25.4% callback requests
• 7.7% scheduling/appointments
• 6.5% repetitive FAQs (hours, location, pricing)
• 7% spam

That's 77%+ of calls that are routine. AI handles these as well as any human - often better, since AI answers faster, transcribes perfectly, and costs nothing extra per call.

Predictable Billing Matters

If a $1,200 surprise bill would cause problems, you can't afford Ruby's billing model. AI's flat $199/month means you know exactly what you're paying. Budget it and forget it.

You Need Real 24/7 Coverage

Contractor whose customers have emergencies at midnight? Medical practice where after-hours calls could be urgent? AI answers every call regardless of time. Ruby's after-hours coverage has limitations and costs more.

Call Volume Is High or Variable

Getting 100+ calls monthly? Volume fluctuates seasonally? AI's unlimited model means you're never penalized for success. One contractor in our research gets 87 calls monthly - with Ruby, that's $600-800/month. With AI, $199.

You're Running a Small Business

Most small businesses don't have $500-1,000/month for phone answering. AI delivers professional call handling at a price point that makes sense for contractors, solo professionals, and growing companies.

How to Switch from Ruby to AI

If you've decided to switch, here's how to do it without losing calls.

Step 1: Before You Switch

Download your Ruby data. Get call logs, transcripts, and any records you might need. You lose access after canceling.

Review your call patterns. How many calls monthly? Average length? What types? This helps configure AI correctly.

Identify complex call needs. Which calls actually need human backup? Plan for routing those to yourself or staff.

Step 2: Set Up AI While Ruby Is Still Active

Sign up for AI receptionist. Setup takes 1-2 hours. Train it on your business information: hours, services, pricing, FAQs, service area.

Test thoroughly. Make test calls. Have friends or staff call. Verify AI handles your common scenarios correctly.

Don't cancel Ruby yet. Keep both running briefly to ensure smooth transition.

Step 3: Switch Your Forwarding

Update call forwarding. Point your business number to AI instead of Ruby. Most phone systems let you change this in minutes.

Test again. Verify live calls reach AI correctly.

Monitor for a week. Check transcripts daily. Address any issues before fully committing.

Step 4: Cancel Ruby

Check your contract. Ruby offers month-to-month, but confirm you're not in an annual term.

Cancel formally. Get confirmation in writing.

Verify final bill. Ensure no surprise charges on your last statement.

The entire transition typically takes 1-2 weeks, with no gap in call coverage.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Ruby Receptionists a good service?

Ruby provides quality live receptionist service with trained US-based professionals. The service itself is generally well-reviewed. The main issues are pricing (per-minute billing creates unpredictable costs) and post-acquisition customer support concerns. For businesses with budget flexibility who need extensive human conversation, Ruby can work well.

Why did Ruby face a $12 million lawsuit?

In 2021, Ruby was ordered to pay $12 million in damages following a class action lawsuit alleging deceptive billing practices. Customers reported unexpected charges, bills jumping dramatically without warning, and being charged for hangups and spam calls. The per-minute billing model that caused these problems remains in place.

How much cheaper is AI receptionist vs Ruby?

Significantly cheaper. AI receptionist at $199/month flat costs $2,388/year. Ruby's 100-minute plan at $319/month (often exceeded) costs $3,828+/year before overages. Most businesses save $1,500-8,000+ annually switching to AI, depending on call volume.

Can AI handle calls as well as Ruby's human receptionists?

For routine calls (60-70% of typical business calls) - FAQs, scheduling, messages, basic information - AI handles them as well or better. AI answers faster, transcribes perfectly, and works 24/7. For complex situations, upset customers, or high-value sales conversations, humans remain superior. The question is what percentage of YOUR calls are routine vs complex.

Will my customers know they're talking to AI?

Modern AI receptionists sound natural and conversational, not robotic. Many callers don't realize they're talking to AI for routine interactions. You can have AI identify itself for transparency. Most customers care more about getting answers quickly than who (or what) provides them.

What if I need both AI and human coverage?

Many businesses use a hybrid approach: AI handles the 60-70% of routine calls, then routes complex situations to human follow-up. This gives you 24/7 AI coverage plus human expertise where it matters - at a fraction of Ruby's cost. Set up AI to transfer specific call types (emergencies, upset callers, high-value inquiries) directly to your cell or staff.

The Bottom Line: Premium Service, Problematic Pricing

Ruby Receptionists built a legitimate business providing quality live receptionist service. The humans are real, the training is professional, and the brand is established.

The problem isn't the service. It's the pricing model.

Per-minute billing with high overage rates and no alerts punishes small businesses with unpredictable costs. The $12 million class action settlement wasn't about bad service - it was about billing practices that surprise and frustrate customers.

For businesses where extended human conversation is essential and budget allows $500-1,000+/month, Ruby remains a viable option. Their strengths in empathy, complex intake, and human judgment are genuine.

But for the majority of small businesses - contractors, service providers, solo professionals - where most calls are routine, predictable costs matter, and 24/7 coverage is valuable, AI receptionist is the clear winner.

$199/month flat. Unlimited calls. No surprises.

That's what phone answering should cost.

Ready to Stop Missing Customer Calls?

Try NextPhone's AI receptionist free for 7 days. See how other small businesses are capturing more leads 24/7.

Get Started

Try NextPhone free for 14 days. See how AI handles your calls. Compare your Ruby bills to $199/month flat.

• [Start Your Free 14-Day Trial - No Credit Card Required]

Related Articles

• AI Receptionist vs Human Receptionist: The Honest 2025 Comparison
• AI Receptionist: The Complete 2025 Guide
• AI Receptionist Pricing: What Does It Really Cost?
• Best AI Receptionist for Small Business
• Smith.ai vs NextPhone: Which AI Receptionist Is Right for You?