Key Takeaways

Answering service costs range from $99/month (basic) to $1,695+/month (premium live services)

Live receptionist services typically charge per-minute or per-call; AI services often use flat-rate pricing

Ruby, Smith.ai, and AnswerConnect are the leading traditional live answering providers

AI-powered solutions like NextPhone offer unlimited calls at predictable monthly rates ($199/month)

Your call volume, call complexity, and budget should drive your decision

A traditional in-house receptionist costs $35,000-$45,000 per year, making outsourced services cost-effective for most businesses

Every missed call represents a missed opportunity. Yet according to a study by 411 Locals, businesses only answer 37.8% of their inbound calls on average. Another 37.8% end up in voicemail, and 24.3% receive no response at all. With 67% of callers refusing to leave voicemails for businesses, that's a lot of potential customers walking away.

An answering service solves this problem by ensuring every call gets answered, whether by a live receptionist or an AI-powered system. But with dozens of providers offering different pricing models, features, and approaches, choosing the right one can feel overwhelming.

This answering service comparison breaks down the major players in the market, compares their pricing and features side-by-side, and helps you determine which type of service best fits your business needs.

Types of Answering Services Explained

Ready to Stop Missing Customer Calls?

Try NextPhone's AI receptionist free for 7 days. See how other small businesses are capturing more leads 24/7.

Get Started

Before diving into specific providers, understanding the three main categories of answering services will help frame your decision.

Traditional Live Answering Services

Live answering services employ real human receptionists who answer calls on behalf of your business. These professionals work from call centers and are trained to follow your scripts, capture caller information, schedule appointments, and transfer calls as needed.

Most live services charge per minute or per call, with monthly packages that include a set number of minutes. Overages are common and can significantly increase costs. The primary advantage is the human touch—callers interact with a real person who can demonstrate empathy, handle nuanced situations, and adapt to unexpected requests.

Leading live answering services include Ruby Receptionists, AnswerConnect, Moneypenny, and the human tier of Smith.ai.

AI-Powered Answering Services

AI answering services use natural language processing and machine learning to handle calls automatically. Modern AI systems can understand caller intent, answer questions, schedule appointments, route calls, and capture information—all without human intervention.

The cost structure typically favors flat-rate pricing or lower per-call fees, making AI services more economical for businesses with high call volumes. AI also handles unlimited simultaneous calls, meaning no caller ever gets a busy signal or waits on hold.

The tradeoff is the lack of human connection. While AI has improved dramatically, some callers still prefer speaking with a person, especially for complex or emotionally sensitive matters.

Hybrid Solutions

A growing category combines AI efficiency with human backup. These services use AI to handle routine calls while routing complex situations to live receptionists. This approach balances cost control with the ability to provide human touch when needed.

Smith.ai pioneered this model with their AI receptionist tier that seamlessly escalates to human agents when necessary.

Answering Service Comparison Table

Feature	Ruby	Smith.ai	AnswerConnect	Moneypenny	NextPhone
Monthly Starting Price	$319	$292.50	$325	$189	$199
Pricing Model	Per-call	Per-call	Per-minute	Per-minute	Flat rate
Included Calls/Minutes	Varies by plan	30 calls	100 minutes	30 minutes	Unlimited
Overage Cost	$5.19/call	$9.75/call	$2.95/min	$2.99/min	None
Setup Fee	None	None	$75	$1,000	None
24/7 Availability	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes
Live Human Receptionists	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	No (AI)
AI Option	No	Yes	No	No	Yes
CRM Integration	Limited	Extensive	25+ tools	Yes	Yes
HIPAA Compliant	No	Add-on	No	Yes	No
Bilingual	Limited	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes
Best For	Premium service	Flexibility	Human-first	Legal/Medical	Cost control

AI vs. Live Answering Services: Making the Right Choice

The fundamental decision many businesses face is whether to choose AI or live answering. Both have legitimate use cases.

When to Choose Live Answering Services

Live receptionists remain the better choice when:

Your industry is complex or sensitive. Legal intake, medical triage, financial advising, and other specialized fields often require nuanced understanding that humans provide. A live receptionist can ask clarifying questions, demonstrate empathy, and exercise judgment in ways AI cannot fully replicate.

Callers expect a personal touch. High-end professional services, luxury brands, and relationship-driven businesses often find that human answering aligns better with their brand positioning. Some client bases simply expect to speak with a person.

Calls require significant judgment. When the "right" response depends heavily on context, tone, or emotional intelligence, humans excel. This includes handling complaints, de-escalating frustrated callers, or managing sensitive situations.

When to Choose AI Answering Services

AI answering makes more sense when:

Call volume is high. At 500+ calls per month, AI's flat-rate pricing delivers substantial savings compared to per-minute or per-call alternatives. The math becomes increasingly favorable as volume grows.

Calls are relatively straightforward. Appointment scheduling, business hours inquiries, basic information requests, and call routing are ideal AI use cases. If 80% of your calls follow predictable patterns, AI handles them efficiently.

Budget is a primary concern. For businesses watching every dollar, AI answering provides 24/7 professional call handling at a fraction of live service costs. A traditional in-house receptionist costs $35,000-$45,000 annually; NextPhone's $199/month is roughly $2,400/year.

Scalability matters. Growing businesses or those with seasonal spikes benefit from AI's ability to handle unlimited simultaneous calls without additional cost. Live services require negotiating new plans as volume increases.

The Cost Reality

Understanding true costs requires looking beyond base monthly fees:

In-house receptionist: $35,000-$45,000/year including salary, benefits, and overhead. Limited to one person handling one call at a time, with breaks, sick days, and vacation.

Live answering services: $300-$2,000+/month depending on volume. A business receiving 300 calls averaging 2 minutes each would use 600 minutes—well beyond most included packages, triggering significant overages.

AI answering services: $99-$300/month typically flat rate. The same 300-call scenario costs the same as 50 calls.

Consider this example: A business receives 400 calls per month. With AnswerConnect at $2.95/minute overage and assuming 2-minute average calls, they'd pay $325 base plus roughly $1,770 in overages (600 minutes over the 100 included) = nearly $2,100/month. With NextPhone at $199/month flat, the savings approach $23,000 annually.

How to Choose the Right Answering Service

Assess Your Call Volume

Before comparing services, understand your current call patterns:

Track inbound calls for 30 days minimum
Note peak hours and days
Calculate average call duration
Identify the percentage that are spam or wrong numbers

This data reveals which pricing model—per-minute, per-call, or flat-rate—serves you best. High-volume callers benefit from flat-rate; low-volume callers may find per-call competitive.

Understand Your Call Complexity

Categorize the types of calls you receive:

Simple: Hours inquiries, basic info, appointment scheduling Moderate: Sales questions, service requests, general support Complex: Legal intake, medical symptoms, emotional situations, complaints

If most calls are simple or moderate, AI handles them capably. Complex calls may require human judgment.

Set Your Budget

Calculate what missed calls cost your business today. If your average customer is worth $500 and you miss 20 calls monthly that would have converted, that's $10,000 in lost revenue—making even premium answering services cost-effective.

Determine your acceptable monthly investment, but account for the true total cost including:

Base monthly fee
Likely overages based on your volume
Setup fees
Add-on features you'll need

Evaluate Integration Needs

Modern answering services should connect with your existing tools:

CRM systems (Salesforce, HubSpot, Zoho)
Calendar applications (Google Calendar, Calendly)
Practice management software (Clio for legal, industry-specific tools)
Communication platforms (Slack, email)

Verify that your chosen service integrates with your tech stack before committing.

What to Avoid When Choosing an Answering Service

Navigate the selection process carefully by watching for:

Hidden fees and setup costs. Some providers advertise low monthly rates but charge $500-$1,000+ for setup, training, or configuration. Ask for complete pricing upfront.

Aggressive per-minute rounding. Services that round to the nearest minute or 30-second increment inflate costs significantly on short calls. A 15-second call rounded to 30 seconds costs double.

Charges for unwanted calls. Quality providers filter spam and don't charge for wrong numbers. Others bill for every call regardless of legitimacy.

Long-term contracts. Month-to-month flexibility allows you to switch if service quality declines. Be wary of annual commitments with cancellation penalties.

Poor response time guarantees. The best services answer within 3-4 rings. Ask about their average speed of answer and hold time metrics.

Mismatched compliance. If you're in healthcare, legal, or financial services, verify the provider meets your compliance requirements (HIPAA, attorney-client privilege protections, etc.) before signing.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much does an answering service cost?

Answering service pricing varies widely based on the type and volume. Basic AI services start around $99/month, while premium live receptionist services range from $245 to $1,695+ per month. Most live services include a set number of minutes with overage charges of $2-5 per minute beyond that. Flat-rate services like NextPhone charge $199/month for unlimited calls, making costs completely predictable.

What's the difference between a virtual receptionist and an answering service?

The terms are often used interchangeably, though "virtual receptionist" sometimes implies more personalized, dedicated service where the same person regularly handles your calls. Traditional "answering services" may route calls to whoever is available in a larger pool. Functionally, both answer calls, take messages, schedule appointments, and transfer callers as needed.

Can an AI answering service handle complex calls?

AI answering services handle routine calls exceptionally well—scheduling, basic questions, hours inquiries, and call routing. For complex situations requiring judgment, empathy, or extensive back-and-forth, AI has limitations. Many businesses find that 70-80% of their calls are routine enough for AI, with only a small percentage requiring human intervention. Hybrid services can escalate complex calls to live agents when needed.

How do per-minute vs per-call pricing models compare?

Per-minute pricing charges based on actual talk time, making costs variable and sometimes unpredictable. Short calls are economical; longer calls add up fast. Per-call pricing charges a flat fee regardless of duration, providing more predictability but potentially higher costs for brief calls. Flat-rate pricing (like NextPhone) eliminates both concerns by including unlimited calls for one monthly price.

Are answering services worth it for small businesses?

For most small businesses, answering services provide strong ROI. Consider: if missing 10 calls per month costs you just 2 customers worth $300 each, that's $600/month in lost revenue. A $199/month answering service pays for itself immediately. Beyond revenue, professional call handling improves customer experience and frees you to focus on running your business rather than watching the phone.

Can I switch answering services easily?

Most modern providers offer month-to-month service after any initial commitment period. Switching typically involves setting up the new service, testing it, then redirecting your call forwarding. Keep your business phone number (it's yours), and the transition is usually seamless. Watch for contract terms, early termination fees, and any number porting requirements before signing with any provider.

How do answering services integrate with my existing phone system?

Integration typically works through call forwarding—you forward your existing business number to the answering service during specified hours or when calls go unanswered. Many services also offer dedicated local or toll-free numbers. VoIP phone systems often integrate more directly, allowing sophisticated routing rules. Most providers connect with CRM systems, calendars, and business tools via native integrations or Zapier.

Making Your Decision

Choosing an answering service ultimately comes down to three factors: your call volume, call complexity, and budget.

High complexity, premium budget: Ruby or AnswerConnect provide the human touch that sensitive or sophisticated call handling requires.

Moderate complexity, seeking flexibility: Smith.ai offers the choice between AI and human with per-call predictability.

High volume, cost-conscious: NextPhone's flat-rate unlimited model delivers maximum value for businesses fielding many calls.

Regulated industries: Moneypenny's HIPAA compliance and legal expertise serve healthcare and law practices well.

The worst outcome is continuing to miss calls because you're paralyzed by choice. Every answering service on this list outperforms the voicemail-and-hope approach most businesses currently use.

Evaluate your specific needs, calculate your true costs under each pricing model, and choose a provider whose strengths match your priorities. Your future customers—the ones who won't end up in voicemail—will thank you.

Last updated: November 2024

Internal Links:

AI phone answering service guide
Virtual receptionist comparison
Business phone system features
NextPhone pricing

Answering Service Comparison: Finding the Right Solution for Your Business